The Falcons have had a quarterback dilemma ever since they failed to land Deshaun Watson and subsequently traded franchise legend Matt Ryan. The irony of that, five years later, is astounding. Missing out on Watson turned out to be one of the best things that ever happened to the Falcons, and Ryan is now Atlanta’s President of Football — leading a front office whose top priority is solving the most important position in all of sports.

Ryan inherited Michael Penix Jr. from the previous regime. A man entering his third season in the league and coming off yet another devastating knee injury, Penix flashed enough as a full-time starter last year to prove he belongs — but whether that’s as a starter or a backup remains to be seen.

Enter Tua Tagovailoa, who the Falcons signed to a veteran minimum contract this offseason. Whatever you think about Tua, you cannot beat the price tag. He’s proven to be one of the 32 best quarterbacks in the league since he was drafted, and at his peak he was firmly in the top-10 conversation.

There are also a striking number of similarities between the two. Both are left-handed quarterbacks drafted in the top 10 with long injury histories. For Penix, it’s been lower body issues. For Tua, the concussions.

All signs point to this being a truly open competition heading into Week 1 — but if there’s a leader in the clubhouse, it has to be the veteran out of the University of Alabama.

For starters, Penix still isn’t 100 percent recovered from the ACL injury he suffered last season. There’s a belief he’ll be ready to go by the start of the year, but that still puts him behind the eight ball when it comes to learning an entirely new offense under head coach Kevin Stefanski and offensive coordinator Tommy Rees.

Then there are these words from Stefanski on the most important trait a quarterback can have at this level — accuracy — which he went on to praise Tua for specifically, calling it his “innate, God-given ability.”

#Falcons HC Kevin Stefanski says accuracy is the most important trait for a QB and called Tua Tagovailoa’s accuracy an “innate, God-given ability.” pic.twitter.com/Rp3zNJ7Bjy

— Ari Meirov (@MySportsUpdate) May 27, 2026

Tua has been one of the NFL’s most accurate quarterbacks since the day he entered the league, completing a remarkable 68 percent of his passes over his career and leading the league in completion percentage just a couple of years ago.

Penix, on the other hand, has been wildly inaccurate — completing just 59.6 percent of his passes over his first 12 career starts. If accuracy is what Stefanski is prioritizing, this might not be much of a competition after all.

In the grand scheme of things, it would be better for the organization if Penix wins the job and runs with it — proving himself as the long-term franchise quarterback, and doing so on the remaining years of his rookie deal.

That said, there are three reasons the Falcons aren’t going to hesitate rolling with Tua if he earns it. This regime had nothing to do with drafting Penix. The injury history is far too significant to gloss over. And despite having six times as many career starts, Tua is only two years older than Penix — who spent six seasons in college.

Nobody should assume the Falcons are handing this job to Penix simply because he was a high draft pick a couple of years ago. That’s borderline irrelevant given the circumstances, which should favor Tua’s chances of being the Week 1 starter.

—

(Photo by Jeff Robinson/Icon Sportswire)