ESPN Grades the Braves signing of Evan Phillips

ESPN grades the Braves signing of Evan Phillips

The Braves are one of the few teams to make a significant addition so far this offseason, signing reliever Evan Phillips to a three-year contract worth $35 million.

The bullpen wasn’t the most discussed offseason need in Atlanta, but it was a notable one, all things considered. Raisel Iglesias is currently a free agent, and the plan for now is to move Didier Fuentes back to the rotation to begin the 2027 season. That leaves two sizable holes that must be filled, and the Phillips signing gives them some leeway to execute their plan with Fuentes.

ESPN’s Grade: B-

“Phillips was one of the best relievers in the majors with the Dodgers in 2022-23 before suffering shoulder and elbow injuries at the end of the 2024 season and finally undergoing Tommy John surgery in June 2025. He returned to make 31 appearances with the Dodgers in 2026, finishing with 33 strikeouts and just six walks in 26 innings. The stuff looked good — he was throwing a little harder than pre-injury — although he did serve up five home runs, and his injury history makes a three-year deal a little risky.

The belief was that the Braves’ pitching priority this offseason would be a starter, but signing Phillips will allow them to stretch out Fuentes as a starter in spring training. He does have a three-pitch arsenal in his fastball, slider and splitter, and he has thrown a curveball in the past, so as effective as Fuentes was in relief as a rookie in 2026, it makes sense to see if it can work out for him in the rotation. — Schoenfield”

—

A B- feels about right for this signing. When healthy, he’s been among the most consistently dominant setup relievers in baseball, recording a 2.36 ERA over the last six seasons with the Dodgers, but he did have Tommy John surgery a couple of seasons ago, which presents some risk when talking about a three-year deal.

This move also isn’t really a needle-mover, and that’s the only complaint I have. This rotation is way too reliant on Chris Sale, and the lineup was a massive disappointment a year ago, especially down the stretch and into the postseason. Internal developments could come, but until the Braves get some competent play out of shortstop and left field, it’s going to be hard for them to compete with the National League’s elite again.

Adding another quality reliever is fine. You could even say it was necessary, but it better not stop the Braves from improving other areas of the roster that have been constantly overlooked offseason after offseason.

—

Photo: IMAGO / Newscom World

Share The Love:

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Related News